Chapter in:Linguistic Categories, Language Description and Linguistic Typology
Edited by Luca Alfieri, Giorgio Francesco Arcodia and Paolo Ramat
[Typological Studies in Language 132] 2021
Linguistic categories, language description and linguistic typology – An overview
In this paper we propose a critical discussion of the rationale for this volume. After a short introduction (Section 1), an outline of the long-standing opposition between language particular description and universal grammar in the history of the language sciences is provided (Section 2). This opposition indeed represents the substrate on which our ‘comparative concepts debate’ is based: a summary of the debate, both in the form it had in the lingtyp mailing list (January / February 2016) and in the subsequent monographic issue of Linguistic Typology 2016, is offered in Section 3 and Section 4. Some critical consideration on the debate and on its relation with the various branches of linguistics are presented in Section 5. An overview of the papers included in the volume closes this introduction (Section 6).
Bybee, Joan, Perkins, Revere & Pagliuca, William
Croft, William & van Lier, Eva
Cysouw, Michael & Good, Jeff
Dixon, Robert M.W.
Evans, Nicholas & Levinson, Stephen C.
Greenberg, Joseph H.
2012 How to compare major word classes across languages. In Theories of Everything in Honor of Edward Keenan [UCLA Working Papers in Linguistics Volume 17, Article 16], Thomas Graf, Denis Paperno, Anna Szabolcsi & Jos Tellings (eds), 109–130. Los Angeles CA: UCLA. http://phonetics.linguistics.ucla.edu/wpl/issues/wpl17/wpl17.html (11 November 2020).
2014 (Non-)universality of word-classes and words: The mid-20th century shift. https://hiphilangsci.net/2014/10/08/non-universality-of-word-classes-and-words-the-mid-20th-century-shift/ (11 November 2020).
2019 Can cross-linguistic regularities be explained by constraints on change? In Explanation in Typology: Diachronic Sources, Functional Motivations and the Nature of the Evidence, Karsten Schmidtke-Bode, Natalia Levshina, Susanne M. Michaelis & Ilja A. Seržant (eds), 1–23. Berlin: Language Science Press.
Haspelmath, Martin, Dryer, Matthew S., Gil, David & Comrie, Bernard
Hawkins, John A.
Hurford, James R.
Keenan, Edward L. & Comrie, Bernard
Kuteva, Tania, Heine, Bernd, Hong, Bo, Long, Haiping, Narrog, Heiko & Rhee, Seongha
Lander, Yury & Arkadiev, Peter
LaPolla, Randy J.
Michaelis, Susanne M., Maurer, P., Haspelmath, M. & Huber, M.
Morpurgo Davies, Anna
de Saussure, Ferdinand
Shibatani, Masayoshi & Bynon, Theodora
van der Auwera, Johan & Sahoo, Kalyanamalini