Article published in:Structures, Strategies and Beyond: Studies in honour of Adriana Belletti
Edited by Elisa Di Domenico, Cornelia Hamann and Simona Matteini
[Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today 223] 2015
► pp. 343–368
Minimality effects in children’s passives
Many studies find true verbal passives in English acquired only after age four, but some find three-year-olds fully adultlike. We explain this discrepancy using Relativized Minimality (RM, Rizzi 2004). Collins (2005a) argues the passive involves movement of the logical object across the logical subject (either PRO, or a lexical DP with ‘by’), and normally this requires smuggling. We propose smuggling is maturationally unavailable until age four. Three-year-olds succeed only if the intervener is eliminated, as in certain Romance reflexive-clitic constructions; or if +Topic/+WH on the logical object can prevent an RM violation, as in certain studies of the English passive. Following Grillo (2008), we explain the still-later acquisition of non-actional passives by their need for both smuggling and semantic coercion.
Keywords: language acquisition, maturation, minimality, passive, smuggling
Published online: 27 August 2015
Adani, Flavia, van der Lely, Heather, Forgiarini, Matteo & Guasti, Maria Teresa
Baker, Mark, Johnson, Kyle & Roberts, Ian
Belletti, Adriana & Contemori, Carla
Belletti, Adriana, Friedmann, Naama, Brunato, Dominique & Rizzi, Luigi
Bever, Thomas G.
Borer, Hagit & Wexler, Kenneth
Cipriani, Paola, Pfanner, Pietro, Chilosi, Anna, Cittadoni, Lorena, Ciuti, Alessandro, Maccari, Anna, Pantano, Natalia, Pfanner, Lucia, Poli, Paola, Sarno, Stefania, Bottari, Piero, Cappelli, Giuseppe, Colombo, C. & Veneziano, Edy
Crain, Stephen, Thornton, Rosalind & Murasugi, Keiko
2004 The Acquisition of the Sesotho Passive: Reanalyzing a Counterexample to Maturation. MA thesis, Boston University.
2012 Developmental Perspectives on the Acquisition of the Passive. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Connecticut.
De Cat, Cécile & Plunkett, Bernadette
Demuth, Katherine, Moloi, Francina & Machobane, Malillo
de Villiers, Jill & de Villiers, Peter
Friedmann, Naama, Belletti, Adriana & Rizzi, Luigi
Friedmann, Naama & Costa, Joao
Friedmann, Naama, & Costa, Joao
Froud, Karen, Tsakali, Vina & Wexler, Kenneth
2010 Late maturation of Raising in English: Evidence from typically developing children. Poster presented at Generative Approaches to Language Acquisition: North America (GALANA), Philadelphia PA, September.
Ganger, Jennifer, Dunn, Sabrina & Gordon, Peter
Gavarró, Anna & Parramon, Xavier
2011 The acquisition of Catalan passives and the adjectival interpretation. Paper presented at the Linguistic Symposium on Romance Languages, University of Ottawa, May.
Gehrke, Berit & Grillo, Nino
Gorden, Peter & Chafetz, Jill
Gualmini, Andrea, Hulsey, Sarah, & Hacquard, Valentine
Hirsch, Christopher & Wexler, Kenneth
2004 Who seems to rescue raising. Poster presented at the Inaugural Conference on Generative Approaches to Language Acquisition – North America, University of Hawai’i at Manoa, December.
Hirsch, Christopher, Modyanova, Nadia & Wexler, Kenneth
2006 Predicting passive acquisition: Environmental factors and biological maturation. Paper presented at Scandinavian Conference of Linguistics, Workshop in Language Acquisition, Aalborg, Denmark.
Hirsch, Christopher & Wexler, Kenneth
Hirsch, Christopher, Orfitelli, Robyn, & Wexler, Kenneth
2007 When seem means think: The role of the experiencer-phrase in children’s comprehension of raising. In Galana 2 – Proceedings of the Conference on Generative Approaches to Language Acquisition North America 2, Alyona Belikova, Luisa Meroni & Mari Umeda (eds), 135–146. Somerville MA: Cascadilla Press.
2011 The Acquisition of Raising. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT.
Hyams, Nina & Snyder, William
2005 Young children never smuggle: Reflexive clitics and the Universal Freezing Hypothesis. Paper presented at the Boston University Conference on Language Development, 5 November 2005. http://web.uconn.edu/snyder/papers/HyamsSnyder05.pdf
2006 Young children are frozen: Reflexive clitics and the Universal Freezing Hypothesis. Ms, UCLA/UConn. http://web.uconn.edu/snyder/papers/Hyams_Snyder_2006.pdf
2003 L’acquisizione dei verbi inaccusativi: Studio sull’acquisizione spontanea dei parlanti. MA thesis, University of Siena.
Lorusso, Paolo, Caprin, Claudia & Guasti, Maria-Teresa
2005 Overt subject distribution in early Italian children. Supplement Proceeding of Boston University Conference on Language Development . http://www.bu.edu/linguistics/APPLIED/BUCLD
2012 The Acquisition of Italian Passives: Evidence from Comprehension, Production and Syntactic Priming Studies. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Siena.
Manetti, Claudia & Belletti, Adriana
2013 Causatives and the acquisition of the Italian passive. Paper presented at GALA 2013, University of Oldenburg, Germany.
Maratsos, Michael P., Fox, Dana, Becker, Judith & Chalkley, Mary Ann
2002 Vdef & MLC: Why English passives might be tough for kids. Ms, MIT.
O’Brien, Karen, Elaine Grolla & Lillo-Martin, Diane
2012b Argument Intervention in the Acquisition of A-movement. Ph.D. dissertation, UCLA.
Pinker, Steven, LeBeaux, David S. & Frost, Loren Ann
Snyder, William, Hyams, Nina & Crisma, Paola
Snyder, William & Hyams, Nina
2008 Children’s passives: The role of discourse features. Paper presented in the Psycholinguistics Brownbag Series, University of Connecticut, Storrs. http://web.uconn.edu/snyder/papers/Snyder_Hyams_2008.pdf (6 September 2008).
2008 Reflexive constructions in French (and in other Romance languages and elsewhere). UCLA Lecture Notes, Spring.
2010 French reflexive se: Binding and Merge locality. http://ling.auf.net/lingBuzz/001273
2001 Move Dissolves into Merge: A Theory of Locality. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Geneva.
Stromswold, Karin, Pinker, Steven & Kaplan, Ronald M.
Suppes, Patrick, Smith, Robert & Léveillé, Madeleine
Turner, Elizabeth Ann & Rommetveit, Ragnar
Volpato, Francesca, Tagliaferro, Laura, Verin, Laura & Cardinaletti Anna
Volpato, Francesca, Verin, Laura & Cardinaletti, Anna
2012 The acquisition of passives in Italian: Auxiliaries and answering strategies in an experiment of elicited production. Paper presented at The Romance Turn V, Universidade Nova de Lisboa.
Cited by 16 other publications
No author info given
Belletti, Adriana & Claudia Manetti
Borga, Jason & William Snyder
CHOE, JINSUN & WILLIAM O'GRADY
de Lima Júnior, João Claudio, Marina Rosa Ana Augusto & Letícia Maria Sicuro Corrêa
de Lima Júnior, João Claudio, Letícia Maria Sicuro Corrêa & Marina Rosa Ana Augusto
GRILLO, NINO, ARTEMIS ALEXIADOU, BERIT GEHRKE, NILS HIRSCH, CATERINA PAOLAZZI & ANDREA SANTI
Jensen de López, Kristine, Kristen Schroeder & Anna Gavarró
Mateu, Victoria & Nina Hyams
Mateu, Victoria & Nina Hyams
Mateu, Victoria Eugenia
Paolazzi, Caterina Laura, Nino Grillo, Artemis Alexiadou & Andrea Santi
Pinto, Manuela & Shalom Zuckerman
Sanfelici, Emanuela & Petra Schulz
Santos, Ana Lúcia, Anabela Gonçalves & Nina Hyams
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 08 june 2021. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.