Article published in:
Experimental Semiotics: A new approach for studying the emergence and the evolution of human communicationEdited by Bruno Galantucci and Simon Garrod
[Interaction Studies 11:1] 2010
► pp. 33–50
Can iterated learning explain the emergence of graphical symbols?
Simon Garrod | University of Glasgow/University of Western Australia
Nicolas Fay | University of Western Australia
Shane Rogers | University of Western Australia
Bradley Walker | University of Western Australia
Nik Swoboda | Universidad Politecnia de Madrid
This paper contrasts two influential theoretical accounts of language change and evolution – Iterated Learning and Social Coordination. The contrast is based on an experiment that compares drawings produced with Garrod et al’s (2007) ‘pictionary’ task with those produced in an Iterated Learning version of the same task. The main finding is that Iterated Learning does not lead to the systematic simplification and increased symbolicity of graphical signs produced in the standard interactive version of the task. A second finding is that Iterated Learning leads to less conceptual and structural alignment between participants than observed for those in the interactive condition. The paper concludes with a comparison of the two accounts in relation to how each promotes signs that are effi cient, systematic and learnable.
Published online: 04 March 2010
https://doi.org/10.1075/is.11.1.04gar
https://doi.org/10.1075/is.11.1.04gar
Cited by
Cited by 38 other publications
Bebbington, Keely, Colin MacLeod, T. Mark Ellison & Nicolas Fay
2017. The sky is falling: evidence of a negativity bias in the social transmission of information.
Evolution and Human Behavior 38:1 ► pp. 92 ff. 
Christensen, Peer, Riccardo Fusaroli & Kristian Tylén
2016. Environmental constraints shaping constituent order in emerging communication systems: Structural iconicity, interactive alignment and conventionalization.
Cognition 146 ► pp. 67 ff.
Cornish, Hannah, Rick Dale, Simon Kirby, Morten H. Christiansen & Robert C Berwick
2017. Sequence Memory Constraints Give Rise to Language-Like Structure through Iterated Learning.
PLOS ONE 12:1 ► pp. e0168532 ff.
Cuskley, Christine
2019. Alien forms for alien language: investigating novel form spaces in cultural evolution.
Palgrave Communications 5:1
de Boer, Bart
2015. Biology, culture, evolution and the cognitive nature of sound systems.
Journal of Phonetics 53 ► pp. 79 ff.
de Boer, Bart
2015. Evolution of speech-specific cognitive adaptations.
Frontiers in Psychology 6
de Boer, Bart, Wendy Sandler & Simon Kirby
2012. New perspectives on duality of patterning: Introduction to the special issue.
Language and Cognition 4:4 ► pp. 251 ff.
DE BOER, BART & TESSA VERHOEF
2012. LANGUAGE DYNAMICS IN STRUCTURED FORM AND MEANING SPACES.
Advances in Complex Systems 15:03n04 ► pp. 1150021 ff.
Eryilmaz, Kerem & Hannah Little
2017. Using leap motion to investigate the emergence of structure in speech and language.
Behavior Research Methods 49:5 ► pp. 1748 ff.
Fan, Judith E., Robert D. Hawkins, Mike Wu & Noah D. Goodman
2020. Pragmatic Inference and Visual Abstraction Enable Contextual Flexibility During Visual Communication.
Computational Brain & Behavior 3:1 ► pp. 86 ff.
Fay, Nicolas, Michael Arbib & Simon Garrod
2013. How to Bootstrap a Human Communication System.
Cognitive Science 37:7 ► pp. 1356 ff.
Fay, Nicolas, Mark Ellison & Simon Garrod
2014. Iconicity.
Pragmatics & Cognition 22:2 ► pp. 244 ff.
Fay, Nicolas, T. Mark Ellison & Christine A. Caldwell
2013. The Cultural Evolution of Human Communication Systems in Different Sized Populations: Usability Trumps Learnability.
PLoS ONE 8:8 ► pp. e71781 ff.
Fay, Nicolas, Casey J. Lister, T. Mark Ellison & Susan Goldin-Meadow
2014. Creating a communication system from scratch: gesture beats vocalization hands down.
Frontiers in Psychology 5
Fay, Nicolas, Bradley Walker, Nik Swoboda & Simon Garrod
2018. How to Create Shared Symbols.
Cognitive Science 42 ► pp. 241 ff.
Fay, Nicolas, Bradley Walker, Nik Swoboda, Ichiro Umata, Takugo Fukaya, Yasuhiro Katagiri & Simon Garrod
2018. Universal Principles of Human Communication: Preliminary Evidence From a Cross-cultural Communication Game.
Cognitive Science 42:7 ► pp. 2397 ff.
Fröhlich, Marlen, Christine Sievers, Simon W. Townsend, Thibaud Gruber & Carel P. Schaik
2019. Multimodal communication and language origins: integrating gestures and vocalizations.
Biological Reviews 94:5 ► pp. 1809 ff.
Galantucci, Bruno
2011. The cultural approach to language is ripe, let us expand our options to test it empirically.
Physics of Life Reviews 8:4 ► pp. 363 ff.
Galantucci, Bruno, Simon Garrod & Gareth Roberts
2012. Experimental Semiotics.
Language and Linguistics Compass 6:8 ► pp. 477 ff.
GALANTUCCI, BRUNO & GARETH ROBERTS
2012. EXPERIMENTAL SEMIOTICS: AN ENGINE OF DISCOVERY FOR UNDERSTANDING HUMAN COMMUNICATION.
Advances in Complex Systems 15:03n04 ► pp. 1150026 ff.
Hawkins, Robert X.D., Noah D. Goodman & Robert L. Goldstone
2019. The Emergence of Social Norms and Conventions.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 23:2 ► pp. 158 ff.
Kirby, Simon, Tom Griffiths & Kenny Smith
2014. Iterated learning and the evolution of language.
Current Opinion in Neurobiology 28 ► pp. 108 ff.
Lister, C.J., B. Walker & N. Fay
2020. Innovation and enculturation in child communication: a cross-sectional study.
Evolutionary Human Sciences 2
Lister, Casey J. & Nicolas Fay
2017. How to create a human communication system.
Interaction Studies. Social Behaviour and Communication in Biological and Artificial Systems 18:3 ► pp. 314 ff.
Nettle, Daniel
2012. Social scale and structural complexity in human languages.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 367:1597 ► pp. 1829 ff.
Nguyen, Noël & Véronique Delvaux
2015. Role of imitation in the emergence of phonological systems.
Journal of Phonetics 53 ► pp. 46 ff.
Nowak, Iga & Giosuè Baggio
2016. The emergence of word order and morphology in compositional languages via multigenerational signaling games.
Journal of Language Evolution 1:2 ► pp. 137 ff.
Pesce, Emanuele & Giovanni Montana
2020. Improving coordination in small-scale multi-agent deep reinforcement learning through memory-driven communication.
Machine Learning 109:9-10 ► pp. 1727 ff.
Pleyer, Michael, Stefan Hartmann, James Winters & Jordan Zlatev
2017. Interaction and iconicity in the evolution of language.
Interaction Studies. Social Behaviour and Communication in Biological and Artificial Systems 18:3 ► pp. 303 ff.
Ragir, Sonia & Patricia J. Brooks
2012. The key to cultural innovation lies in the group dynamic rather than in the individual mind.
Behavioral and Brain Sciences 35:4 ► pp. 237 ff.
Ravignani, Andrea, Tania Delgado & Simon Kirby
2017. Musical evolution in the lab exhibits rhythmic universals.
Nature Human Behaviour 1:1
Rogers, Shane L., Nicolas Fay & Rachel L Kendal
2016. Stick or Switch: A Selection Heuristic Predicts when People Take the Perspective of Others or Communicate Egocentrically.
PLOS ONE 11:7 ► pp. e0159570 ff.
Schmitz, Laura, Cordula Vesper, Natalie Sebanz & Günther Knoblich
2018. When Height Carries Weight: Communicating Hidden Object Properties for Joint Action.
Cognitive Science 42:6 ► pp. 2021 ff.
Scott-Phillips, Thomas C. & Simon Kirby
2010. Language evolution in the laboratory.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 14:9 ► pp. 411 ff.
Steels, Luc
2011. Modeling the cultural evolution of language.
Physics of Life Reviews 8:4 ► pp. 339 ff.
Tamariz, Monica, T. Mark Ellison, Dale J. Barr & Nicolas Fay
2014. Cultural selection drives the evolution of human communication systems.
Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 281:1788 ► pp. 20140488 ff.
Tan, Rachael & Nicolas Fay
2011. Cultural transmission in the laboratory: agent interaction improves the intergenerational transfer of information.
Evolution and Human Behavior 32:6 ► pp. 399 ff.
Verhoef, Tessa, Simon Kirby & Bart de Boer
2016. Iconicity and the Emergence of Combinatorial Structure in Language.
Cognitive Science 40:8 ► pp. 1969 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 10 february 2021. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.