Article published in:New Perspectives on the Study of Ser and E star
Edited by Isabel Pérez-Jiménez, Manuel Leonetti and Silvia Gumiel-Molina
[Issues in Hispanic and Lusophone Linguistics 5] 2015
► pp. 119–146
The inference of temporal persistence and the individual/stage level distinction
the case of ser vs. estar in Spanish
In this paper we propose that the differences between ser ‘beSER’ and estar ‘beESTAR’ predications traditionally associated with the individual-level/stagelevel (IL/SL) distinction (having to do with their differing combinations with adverbs quantifying over situations, locative and temporal modifiers, etc.) can be explained without arguing that ser ‘beSER’ and estar ‘beESTAR’ sentences have different event/aspect/Aktionsart-related properties. Specifically, we claim that in copular sentences with adjectival complements, the different kinds of elements that build up the comparison class needed to evaluate adjectival properties can account for the IL/SL character of the predication and that, specifically, the IL/SL distinction is linked to the relative/absolute distinction. This proposal, together with the hypothesis that relative adjectives trigger by default an inference of temporal persistence, can account for all the aforementioned differences between ser ‘beSER’ and estar ‘beESTAR’ sentences. We thus argue for an extension of the explanatory value of the individual/stage-level distinction to the domain of gradability.
Keywords: comparison-class, degree, estar, individual-level, inference of temporal persistence, ser, stage-level
Published online: 28 October 2015
Asher, N., & Morreau, M.
(1992) Individual-level predicates in conditional clauses. Talk given at the Linguistic Society of America Annual Meeting. Philadelphia, PA: January 9–12, 1992.
(1991) Evidence for DegP. In NELS 22 Proceedings of the North East Linguistic Society (pp. 33–47). Amherst, MA: GLSA Publications.
Fernández Leborans, M.J.
Franco, F., & Steinmetz, D.
Gallego, Á., & Uriagereka, J.
(2009) Estar=Ser+P. Paper presented at the XIX Colloquium on Generative Grammar. Universidad del País Vasco, Vitoria-Gasteiz, Spain: April 1–3, 2009.
Gumiel-Molina, S., Moreno-Quibén, N., & Pérez-Jiménez, I.
Gumiel-Molina, S., & Pérez-Jiménez, I.
(2012) Aspectual composition in <ser/estar+adjective> structures: Adjectival scalarity and verbal aspect in copular constructions. Borealis: An International Journal of Hispanic Linguistics, 1, 33–62. Retrieved from http://septentrio.uit.no/index.php/borealis/article/view/2321/2166 DOI:
(2012) What information structure tells us about individual/stage-level predicates. Borealis. An International Journal of Hispanic Linguistics, 1, 1–32. Retrieved from http://septentrio.uit.no/index.php/borealis/article/view/2293 DOI:
Krifka, M., Pelletier, F.J., Carlson, G.N., ter Meulen, A., Chierchia, G., & Link, G.
(2003) Against a davidsonian analysis of copula sentences. In NELS 33 Proceedings of the North East Linguistic Society (pp. 167–186). Amherst, MA: GLSA Publications.
Schmitt, C., & Miller, K.
de Swart, H.
Toledo, A., & Sasoon, G.
(2011) Absolute vs. relative adjectives – variance within vs. between individuals. In N. Ashton, A. Chereches & D. Lutz (Eds.), Proceedings of Semantic and Linguistic Theory 21. ELanguage, 135–154. Retrieved from http://elanguage.net/journals/salt/article/view/21.135