Article published in:
Historiographia Linguistica
Vol. 39:2/3 (2012) ► pp. 279–303

On extremes in linguistic complexity

Phonetic accounts of Iroquoian, Polynesian and Khoesan

| Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań
| Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań
This article examines common motifs in the accounts of the sound systems of Iroquoian, Polynesian and Khoesan languages as the most well-known cases of extremes in phonetic complexity. On the basis of examples from European and American scholarship between the 17th and early 20th century, we investigate continuities in the description of their seemingly ‘exotic’ inventories and phonotactic structures when viewed from the perspective of European languages. We also demonstrate the influence of phonetic accounts on the interpretation of other components of language and their role in the construction of biased images of the languages and their speakers. Finally, we show that controversies in descriptions of ‘exotic’ languages concern issues that remain relevant in modern phonetic research, in particular complexity of phonological systems, while notions which were conceived as ‘misconceptions’ have re-emerged as unresolved research questions, e.g., the status of clicks and small and large consonant inventories.
Published online: 23 November 2012
https://doi.org/10.1075/hl.39.2-3.05kil
References

References

Adelung, Johann Christoph
1806 Mithridates oder allgemeine Sprachenkunde mit dem Vater Unser als Sprachprobe in bey nahe fünfhundert Sprachen und Mundarten. Vol. I. Berlin: Voss.Google Scholar
Alexander, W[illiam] D.
1864 A Short Synopsis of the Most Essential Points in Hawaiian Grammar: For the use of the pupils of Oahu College. Honolulu, Hawaii: Printed by H. M. Whitney.Google Scholar
Andresen, Julie T.
1990 Linguistics in America, 1769–1924: Critical history. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Andrews, Lorrin
1854 Grammar of the Hawaiian Language. Honolulu, Hawaii: Mission Press.Google Scholar
Appleyard, John Whittle
1850 The Kafir Language: Comprising a sketch of its history; which includes a general classification of South African dialects, ethnographical and geographical: Remarks upon its nature: And a grammar. King William’s Town: Printed for the Wesleyan Missionary Society.Google Scholar
Bastian, Adolf
1860 Der Mensch in der Geschichte: Zur Begründung einer psychologischen Weltanschauung. Vol. I. Leipzig: Otto Wigand.Google Scholar
Beauchamp, William M.
1900 Aboriginal Occupation of New York. Albany, N.Y.: University of the State of New York.Google Scholar
Bindseil, Heinrich Ernst
1838 Abhandlungen zur allgemeinen vergleichenden Sprachlehre. I: Physiologie der Stimmund Sprachlaute; II: Ueber die verschiedenen Bezeichnungsweisen des Genus in den Sprachen. Hamburg: Friedrich Perthes.Google Scholar
Bingham, Hiram
1847 A Residence of Twenty-one Years in the Sandwich Islands; or the civil, religious, and political history of those islands. Hartford: Hezekiah Huntington.Google Scholar
Bleek, W[ilhelm] H[einrich] I[mmanuel]
1862 A Comparative Grammar of South African Languages. Vol. I: Phonology. London: Trübner.Google Scholar
Boas, Franz
1911a “Introduction”. Handbook of American Indian Languages ed. by Franz Boas, Vol. I, 1–83. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.Google Scholar
Brinton, Daniel Garrison
1888 “The Language of Palæolithic Man”. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 25.212–225.Google Scholar
Cass, Lewis
1826 “Indians of North America”. The North American Review 22.53–93.Google Scholar
Chafe, Wallace L.
1996 “Sketch of Seneca, an Iroquoian language”. Languages ed. by Ives Goddard (= Handbook of North American Indians, 17), 551–579. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.Google Scholar
Chamisso, Adelbert von
1837 Über die Hawaiische Sprache. Leipzig: In der Weidmannischen Buchhandlung.Google Scholar
Charlevoix, P[ierre François Xavier] de
1744 Histoire et description generale de la Nouvelle France, avec le journal historique d’un voyage fait par ordre du roi dans l’Amérique septentrionnale. Vol. III. Paris: Chez Rolin Fils, Libraire.Google Scholar
Chomsky, Noam & Morris Halle
1968 The Sound Pattern of English. New York: Harper & Row.Google Scholar
Clark, Ross
2009 “Austronesian Languages”. The World’s Major Languages ed. by Bernard Comrie, 781–790. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Colden, Cadwallader
1747 The History of the Five Indian Nations of Canada, which are Dependent on the Province of New York in America, and are the Barrier between the English and French in that Part of the World. London: Printed for T. Osborne.Google Scholar
Cuoq, Jean-André
1864 Jugement erroné de M. Ernest Renan sur les langues sauvages. Montreal: Typographie d’Eusèbe Senécal.Google Scholar
Daa, Lewis Kr[istian]
1856 “On the Affinities between the Languages of the Northern Tribes of the Old and New Continents”. Transactions of the Philological Society 3:1.251–294.Google Scholar
Diderot, Denis & Jean Le Rond d’Alembert
1765 Encyclopédie ou dictionnaire raisonné des sciences, des arts et des métiers. Vol. VIII. Neufchastel: Samuel Faulche & Compagnie.Google Scholar
Dixon, R[obert] M[alcolm] W[ard]
1997 The Rise and Fall of Languages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Du Ponceau, Peter Stephen & John Heckewelder
1819 “A Correspondence between the Rev. John Heckewelder, of Bethlehem, and Peter S. Duponceau, Esq., Corresponding Secretary of the Historical and Literary Committee of the American Philosophical Society, Respecting the Languages of the American Indians”. Transactions of the Historical and Literary Committee of the American Philosophical Society 1.351–448. Philadelphia.Google Scholar
Dwight, Theodore
1848 “Sketch of the Polynesian Language, Drawn up from Hale’s Ethnology and Philology”. Transactions of the American Ethnological Society 2.223–234.Google Scholar
Everett, Daniel L.
2005 “Cultural Constraints on Grammar and Cognition in Pirahã: Another look at the design features of human language”. Current Anthropology 76.621–646.Google Scholar
Farrar, Frederic W.
1870 Families of Speech: Four lectures delivered before the Royal institution of Great Britain in March, 1869. London: Longmans & Green.Google Scholar
Gil, David
2008 “How Complex are Isolating Languages?”. Language Complexity: Typology, contact, change ed. by Matti Miestamo, Kaius Sinnemäki & Fred Karlsson, 109–131. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins.Google Scholar
2009 “How much Grammar does it Take to Sail a Boat?”. Language Complexity as an Evolving Variable ed. by Geoffrey Sampson, David Gil & Peter Trudgill, 19–33. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Güldemann, Tom & Rainer Vossen
2000 “Khoesan”. African Languages: An introduction ed. by Bernd Heine & Derek Nurse, 99–122. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Hale, Horatio
1846 Ethnography and Philology. Philadelphia: Printed by C. Sherman [United States exploring expedition. During the years 1838, 1839, 1840, 1841, 1842 Under the command of Charles Wilkes, U.S.N.]Google Scholar
ed. 1883 The Iroquois Book of Rites. Philadelphia: D. G. Brinton.Google Scholar
Hanzeli, Victor Egon
1969 Missionary Linguistics in New France. A study of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century descriptions of American Indian languages. The Hague: Mouton.Google Scholar
Herder, Johann Gottfried
1986 [1772] Abhandlung über den Ursprung der Sprache. Berlin: Christian Friedrich Voß. (Translated, with afterwords, by Alexander Gode, in On the Origin of Language. Jean-Jacques Rousseau “Essay on the origin of languages”, Johann Gottfried Herder “Essay on the origin of language” ed. by John Moran & Alexander Gode, 85–166. Chicago & London: University of Chicago Press 1986.)Google Scholar
Hockett, Charles F.
1958 A Course in Modern Linguistics. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Hopkins, Manley
1862 Hawaii: The past, present, and future of its island-kingdom. London: Longman, Green, Longman & Robert.Google Scholar
Jaucourt, Louis de
1765 “Les Hurons”. Encyclopédie ou dictionnaire raisonné des sciences, des arts et des métiers ed. by Denis Diderot & Jean Le Rond d’Alembert, vol. VIII, p. 356. Neufchastel: Samuel Faulche & Compagnie.Google Scholar
Jespersen, Otto
1905 Growth and Structure of the English Language. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner.Google Scholar
Joseph, John E. & Frederick J. Newmeyer
2012 “ ‘All Languages Are Equally Complex’: The rise and fall of a consensus”. Historiographia Linguistica 39:2/3.341–368.Google Scholar
Koerner, E. F. K[onrad]
2002 Toward a History of American Linguistics. London: Routledge. (Paperback ed. 2012.)Google Scholar
Kraitsir, Charles
1852 Glossology: Being a treatise on the nature of language, and on the language of nature. New York: George P. Putnam.Google Scholar
Lafitau, Joseph-François
1724 Moeurs des sauvages ameriquains. Vol. II. Paris: Saugrain l’aîné.Google Scholar
Lahontan, Louis Armand
1703 New Voyages to North-America. Giving a full account of the customs, commerce, religion, and strange opinions of the savages of that country with political remarks upon the courts of Portugal and Denmark and the present state of the commerce of those countries. Vol. II. London: Printed for H. Bonwicke.Google Scholar
Lauzon, Matthew J.
1996 “Savage Eloquence in America and the Linguistic Construction of a British Identity in the 18th Century”. Historiographia Linguistica 23:1/2.123–158.Google Scholar
Lefèvre, André
1894 Race and Language. London: Kegan Paul, Trench & Trübner.Google Scholar
Lewis, M. Paul
ed. 2009 Ethnologue: Languages of the world. 16th ed. Dallas, Tex.: SIL International.Google Scholar
Lounsbury, Floyd G.
1978 “Iroquoian Languages”. Northeast ed. by Bruce G. Trigger (= Handbook of North American Indians, 15), 334–343. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.Google Scholar
Lubbock, John
1889 [1873] The Origin of Civilization and the Primitive Condition of Man; Mental and social condition of savages. 5th ed. London: Longmans & Green.Google Scholar
Maddieson, Ian
2007 “Issues of Phonological Complexity: Statistical analysis of the relationship between syllable structures, segment inventories, and tone contrasts”. Experimental Approaches to Phonology ed. by Maria-Josep Solé, Patrice Speeter Beddor & Manjari Ohala, 93–103. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
2009 “Calculating Phonological Complexity”. Approaches to Phonological Complexity ed. by François Pellegrino, Egidio Marsico, Ioana Chitoran & Christophe Coupé, 85–109. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.Google Scholar
2011a “Consonant Inventories”. The World Atlas of Language Structures Online ed. by Matthew S. Dryer & Martin Haspelmath. Munich: Max Planck Digital Library. (http://​wals​.info​/chapter​/1, consulted on 25 July 2012.)
2011b “Presence of Uncommon Consonants”. The World Atlas of Language Structures Online ed. by Matthew S. Dryer & Martin Haspelmath. Munich: Max Planck Digital Library. (http://​wals​.info​/feature​/19A, consulted on 25 July 2012.)
Miller, Amanda
2011 “The Representation of Clicks”. The Blackwell Companion to Phonology ed. by Marc Van Oostendorp, Colin J. Ewen, Elizabeth Hume & Keren Rice, Vol. I, 416–439. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Mithun, Marianne
1982 “The Synchronic and Diachronic Behavior of Plops, Squeaks, Croaks, and Moans”. International Journal of American Linguistics 48.49–58.Google Scholar
Monboddo, James Burnett
1774 [1773] Of the Origin and Progress of Language. Vol. I. 2nd ed. Edinburgh: Printed for J. Balfour.Google Scholar
Morgan, Lewis Henry
1851 League of the Ho-dé-no-sau-nee, or, Iroquois. Rochester: Sage & Brother.Google Scholar
Morris, Charles
1892 [1889] The Aryan Race; Its origin and its achievements. 2nd ed. Chicago: S. C. Griggs & Co.Google Scholar
Müller, Max
1864 Lectures on the Science of Language. Second series. London: Longman, Green, Longman, Roberts & Green.Google Scholar
Ohala, John J.
2009 “Languages’ Sound Inventories: The devil in the details”. Approaches to Phonological Complexity ed. by François Pellegrino, Egidio Marsico, Ioana Chitoran & Christophe Coupé, 47–58. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Renan, Ernest
1858 De l’origine du langage. Paris: Calmann Lévy.Google Scholar
Richardson, John
1851 Arctic Searching Expedition: A journal of a boat-voyage through Rupert’s Land and the Arctic Sea, in search of the discovery ships under command of Sir John Franklin. Vol. II. London: Longman, Brown, Green & Longmans.Google Scholar
Sagard, Gabriel
1998 [1632] Le grand voyage du pays des Hurons; suivi du Dictionnaire de la langue huronne. Montréal: Presses de l’Université de Montréal. [Originally published as Le grand voyage dv pays des Hvrons, situé en l’Amerique vers la mer douce. Paris: chez Denys Moreav.]Google Scholar
Sampson, Geoffrey
2009 “A Linguistic Axiom Challenged”. Language Complexity as an Evolving Variable ed. by Geoffrey Sampson, David Gil & Peter Trudgill, 1–18. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Sayce, A[rchibald] H[enry]
1874 Principles of Comparative Philology. London: Trübner.Google Scholar
Sayce, A. H.
1880a Introduction to the Science of Language. 2 vols. London: C. Kegan Paul & Co.Google Scholar
Scancarelli, Janine
2005 “Cherokee”. Native Languages of the Southeastern United States ed. by Heather K. Hardy & Janine Scancarelli, 351–384. Lincoln, Nebr.: University of Nebraska Press.Google Scholar
Schreyer, Rüdiger
1996 “Take your Pen and Write. Learning Huron: A documented historical sketch”. … and the Word was God: Missionary linguistics and missionary grammar ed. by Even Hovdhaugen, 77–121. Münster: Nodus.Google Scholar
Schultze, Fritz
1900 Psychologie der Naturvölker. Leipzig: Veit & Co.Google Scholar
Schütz, Albert J.
1994 The Voices of Eden: A history of Hawaiian language studies. Honolulu, Hi.: University of Hawai’i Press.Google Scholar
Shea, John G.
1873 “Languages of the American Indians”. The American Cyclopaedia: A popular dictionary of general knowledge ed. by George Ripley & Charles A. Dana, Vol. I, 407–414. New York: D. Appleton.Google Scholar
Simpson, George
1847 Overland Journey round the World, during the Years 1841 and 1842. Philadelphia: Lea & Blanchard.Google Scholar
Spencer, Herbert
1882 [1874] The Principles of Sociology. Vol. I. 3rd ed. London: Williams & Norgate.Google Scholar
Sweet, Henry
1900 The History of Language. London: Dent.Google Scholar
Thwaites, Reuben Gold
ed. 1896–1901 The Jesuit Relations and Allied Documents: Travels and explorations of the Jesuit missionaries in New France, 1610–1791. The original French, Latin, and Italian texts, with English translations and notes. 73 vols. Cleveland, Ohio: Burrows Brothers.Google Scholar
Tindall, Henry
1857 A Grammar and Vocabulary of the Namaqua-Hottentot Language. Cape Town: A. S. Robertson.Google Scholar
Traill, Anthony
2004 “The Khoesan languages”. Language in South Africa ed. by Rajend Mesthrie, 27–49. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Trudgill, Peter
2011 Sociolinguistic Typology: Social determinants of linguistic complexity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Wilkie, John
1831 “Grammar of the Huron Language, by a Missionary of the Village of Huron Indians at Lorette, near Quebec, Found amongst the Papers of the Mission, and Translated from the Latin”. Transactions of the Literary and Historical Society of Quebec 2.94–198.Google Scholar
Wolfart, Christoph H.
1989 “Lahontan’s Bestseller”. Historiographia Linguistica 16:1/2.1–24.Google Scholar