Article published in:Linguistics in the Netherlands 2018
Edited by Bert Le Bruyn and Janine Berns
[Linguistics in the Netherlands 35] 2018
► pp. 79–96
Do we want more or less variation?
The comparative markers als and dan in Dutch prescriptivism since 1900
The suppression of optional variability is a cornerstone of English prescriptivism. For Dutch, however, it is unknown whether this concept is equally important. The goal of this paper is to investigate which stance towards variation is taken in Dutch prescriptivism, and what arguments are used to support this stance. I address these questions by looking at 236 usage advice items from 73 Dutch prescriptive publications concerning the comparative particles als and dan. This data shows a clear division in the allowance of variation. With the standard comparative (groter als/dan), variation is often allowed, but with equative constructions (even groot als) only one form is ever accepted. Furthermore, the allowance of variation decreases over time. The argumentation that is used shows few patterns, and is frequently completely absent. This indicates the existence of an ipse dixit (‘assertion without proof’) tradition in Dutch prescriptivism since 1900.
Keywords: prescriptivism, Dutch language, comparatives, variation
Published online: 03 December 2018
Hubers, Ferdy & Helen de Hoop
Milroy, James & Leslie Milroy[ p. 92 ]
Peters, Pam, & Wendy Young
Reinarz, Lukas, Hugo de Vos & Helen de Hoop
Stenetorp, Pontus, Sampo Pyysalo, Goran Topić, Tomoka Ohta, Sophie Ananiadou & Jun’ichi Tsujii
Schenkeveld-Van der Dussen, Maria A.
Vandenbussche, Wim, Roland Willemyns, Jetje De Groof & Eline Vanhecke
van der Meulen, Marten
Forthcoming. “Language should be pure and grammatical: Values in prescriptivism in the Netherlands 1917–2016.” Values and Multiplicity: Identity and Fluidity in Prescriptivism and Descriptivism ed. by D. Chapman and J. D. Rawlins Bristol Multilingual Matters
Cited by 2 other publications
Hubers, Ferdy, Theresa Redl, Hugo de Vos, Lukas Reinarz & Helen de Hoop
Hubers, Ferdy, Thijs Trompenaars, Sebastian Collin, Kees De Schepper & Helen De Hoop
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 06 march 2021. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.